Swiss insurer comparison
Swica or Helsana? Here's what we see when we place clients with both
Sanitas or Helsana? Here's what we see when we place clients with both.
Both show up in the top five Swiss health insurers. Both earn identical satisfaction ratings. Neither is the better choice for everyone. Here's what we see after filing claims with both — and what the honest answer depends on.
45 minutes with Robert. Free.
In English · With or
We'll send you a short intake form so we understand your needs before we speak.
Your details
You're booked
Check your email for a calendar invite and a video call link.
What this page is for.
You're here because your shortlist is Sanitas and Helsana. Both are premium-positioned, both score well on satisfaction surveys, and both offer strong digital experiences. The difference is in what each insurer does best — Sanitas speaks English natively, Helsana pays you to stay active. This comparison helps you decide which trade-off fits your life.
If you haven't decided the insurer matters less than the framework, start here: The best health insurance in Switzerland is the one that fits you.
At a glance.
Founded
1958
Sanitas (Zürich)
1997
Helsana (Dübendorf)
Insured persons
~841K
Sanitas
~2.1M
Helsana
Satisfaction
7.9
Sanitas (moneyland)
8.0
Helsana
| Category | Sanitas | Helsana |
|---|---|---|
| Headquarters | Zürich | Dübendorf (ZH) |
| Bonus.ch 2025 | 5.2 / 6 (highest) | 5.1 / 6 |
| Digital experience | Medgate tele-medicine (English-native) | Helsana+ rewards app (Swiss Loyalty Award 2025) |
| Pricing model | Age-band (steep on hospital) | Age-band (steep on hospital) |
| Flagship supplementary | Vital Premium + Medical Private | COMPLETA + PRIMEO |
| English support depth | Native English throughout | Good, not first-language |
Sources: moneyland.ch 2025 · bonus.ch · insurer product pages · BAG 2026
Basic insurance (KVG) — premiums and service.
Both cover identical KVG benefits. In Zürich city, Helsana is cheaper across all models — CHF 533.60 Standard vs Sanitas CHF 563.70 (CHF 30/month difference). On Telmed, the gap narrows: Sanitas CHF 532.70 vs Helsana CHF 540.10. On Hausarzt, Helsana wins again at CHF 533.60 vs Sanitas CHF 538.90.
Sanitas's Medgate tele-medicine runs natively in English — the most practical advantage for expats. Helsana's Helsana+ app handles digital claim submission faster. Both offer English support, but Sanitas goes deeper.
| Model | Sanitas 2026 | Helsana 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Standard | CHF 563.70 | CHF 533.60 |
| Hausarzt | CHF 538.90 | CHF 533.60 |
| Telmed | CHF 532.70 | CHF 540.10 |
CHF/month, CHF 300 franchise, age 35, PLZ 8001. Source: BAG 2026 via PrimAI OKP API.
For basic: Helsana wins on Standard and Hausarzt. Sanitas wins marginally on Telmed. The English-language depth of Sanitas is the tie-breaker for many expats.
Splitting basic and supplementary. You don't have to keep both layers with the same insurer. Many clients choose the cheapest basic and a different insurer for supplementary. We help set it up and review every autumn.
Supplementary insurance — where they really differ.
Both use age-band pricing. Both score well on satisfaction. The difference is in what each insurer does best — language depth vs. gamified wellness.
Where Sanitas wins
Sanitas is the most English-friendly Swiss insurer. Medgate tele-medicine, app, phone, documents — all run natively in English. Medical Private offers genuine worldwide coverage for globally mobile professionals. Vital Premium gives comprehensive outpatient coverage with Priority Access to specialists.
Bonus.ch rates Sanitas highest of the big four at 5.2/6. For expats who don't speak German, Sanitas removes the language barrier entirely.
Fits: English-speaking expats, globally mobile professionals, tele-medicine-first users.
Where Helsana wins
Helsana's Helsana+ app (Swiss Loyalty Award 2025) pays CHF 300+/year for exercising and health milestones. COMPLETA is a clean all-in-one outpatient package. As Switzerland's largest insurer (2.1M clients), the provider network is the widest. Onboarding is the fastest — confirmed coverage in hours.
For expats who are active and will use the rewards app, the CHF 300/year payback is genuine money.
Fits: Active expats, families wanting scale and reliability, fast onboarding seekers.
"Sanitas speaks your language from day one. Helsana rewards you for staying active. The question is whether you need an insurer that understands expats or one that gamifies wellness."
When digital-first met the product sheet.
Anya · 30 · Moscow → Zürich, 2024
English-first, wanted everything digital, didn't want to call anyone. Sanitas Compact One is fully digital with Medgate triage. Helsana BeneFit PLUS also uses Medgate but wraps it in a broader product set.
Sanitas won on the pure digital experience — the onboarding, the app, the English-language Medgate integration felt native. Helsana's app is polished but the product structure underneath is more complex than she needed.
Digital-first isn't about the app. It's about whether the insurer behind the app thinks the same way.
Ethan · 38 · Atlanta → Basel, 2024
Wanted everything on the app — claim submission, policy changes, document access. Sanitas won on UX in the first month. Then he filed a complex claim involving a specialist referral, and Sanitas's automated routing sent it in circles for three weeks.
We moved his supplementary to Helsana after the renewal window. The app is slightly less intuitive, but the claim processing on complex cases is more reliable. Digital-first works until the claim isn't simple.
The app handles the easy claims. The insurer handles the hard ones. Know which you're choosing for.
Fatima · 44 · Dubai → Geneva, 2023
Globally mobile, needed worldwide outpatient coverage. Sanitas Medical Private covers worldwide at private rates. Helsana PRIMEO covers worldwide outpatient but at different reimbursement levels depending on the country.
Sanitas Medical Private won — the coverage is genuinely global without the per-country reimbursement tiers. For someone who sees specialists in three countries, the simplicity of one global rate matters.
Worldwide coverage with asterisks isn't worldwide coverage. Read the reimbursement schedule, not the brochure.
Ben & Chioma · 48 + 45 · London → Zug, 2024
Family of four, two teenagers. Wanted a single insurer for everyone. Helsana's product range is wider — COMPLETA for outpatient, Hospital Flex for the parents, basic BeneFit PLUS for the kids. Sanitas's range is narrower but the underwriting is stricter.
Helsana won on breadth. Sanitas would have added an exclusion on Chioma's pre-existing condition. Helsana accepted without exclusions. For a family, the insurer that says yes to everyone is the insurer you pick.
A family's insurer is only as good as the terms they offer the member with the most complex health history.
Arthur · 62 · London → Lausanne, 2023
Chose Sanitas three years ago for the digital experience. At 62, the experience hadn't changed — but the claims had. Two contested reimbursements in one year, both eventually paid but after weeks of follow-up. He wanted reliability over interface.
We moved him to Helsana on the next renewal. The app is marginally less elegant. The claim processing is measurably faster. At 62, you're buying the claims department, not the login screen.
The digital experience is the first impression. The claims department is the lasting one.
What to watch out for — the fine print.
Sanitas gotchas
- Strict supplementary underwriting — pre-existing conditions more likely to trigger exclusions
- Hospital Liberty tiers escalate steeply at 50+
- Smaller insurer (~841K) means thinner network in some cantons
- No bundled all-in-one supplementary — must assemble from Vital + Hospital Liberty
Helsana gotchas
- PRIMEO "free doctor choice" is outpatient only — hospital needs separate product
- Helsana+ rewards capped; some gym discounts need medical review
- Age-band pricing means COMPLETA at 55 is 60-80% higher than at 35
- "Worldwide" on some products excludes elective surgery abroad
This is the kind of thing we read the contracts for.
How we decide
What Robert asks first.
Between Sanitas and Helsana, the deciding question is 'how important is English-first communication to you, and are you the kind of person who opens health apps?' If English is essential, Sanitas. If you'll actively use a rewards app, Helsana.
— Robert Kolar · Health insurance advisor
When the frame breaks
When the answer is neither.
SWICA for long-term expats who want entry-age pricing (neither Sanitas nor Helsana offers this). CSS for budget-conscious families who want modular dental. Concordia for settled families with complex dental needs. Don't anchor on the shortlist you arrived with.
Common questions
Frequently asked.
Does Sanitas Medgate work in English for tele-medicine?
Does Helsana+ really pay CHF 300/year?
Can I switch between Sanitas and Helsana mid-year?
Which has stricter supplementary underwriting?
Both use age-band pricing — is there any long-term advantage?
Is the consultation really free?
Want us to look at your specific case?
Forty-five minutes, in English, no obligation.
Book your first Swiss insurance reviewOr send us a WhatsApp at +41 76 364 88 88
Your first Swiss insurance review.
Free. 45 minutes. In English. Pick a day that works — we'll ask what it's about, then show times.
What's the review about?